State: Ohio wild animal law doesn't violate rights

COLUMBUS, Ohio - Attorneys for Ohio told a federal appeals court Wednesday that the state's exotic animal law gives owners a pathway to keep the creatures if they choose and doesn't violate their constitutional rights.

Several owners are suing the state's agriculture director over the rules, claiming the choices in the law are illusory.

They contend the law violates the First and Fifth Amendments by limiting their freedom of association and effectively taking their property by requiring them to implant microchips in their animals at their own expense. They argue the law includes impossible hurdles that leave owners who want to operate for-profit businesses only one option: joining zoological groups that private owners dislike.

Ohio strengthened its regulation of exotic animal ownership after a Zanesville man released dozens of his animals from his farm before committing suicide in 2011. Authorities killed most of the animals, including black bears, Bengal tigers and African lions, fearing for the public's safety.

The owners have asked the 6th U.S. District Court of Appeals in Cincinnati to strike down the law.

In a brief filed with the court on Wednesday, the state's attorneys said the owners' "desire to keep animals they cherish is understandable; their constitutional arguments are not."

The owners' attorney has said the only way for his clients to qualify for an exemption under the law is for them to join either the Association of Zoos and Aquariums or the Zoological Association of America -- groups he says are at odds with his clients.

But the state contends the law offers ways for the owners to keep their animals without joining the organizations. For instance, they could apply to get a wildlife shelter permit.

The state's attorneys also argued the law's microchip requirement isn't a governmental invasion of property.

"This requirement in Ohio law is no more a taking than requirements to install license plates on cars, exit signs in buildings, or fences in yards," they wrote.

And they said the issue wasn't ripe for the court to review and should be dismissed. The owners don't have a final administrative decision from the state requiring that their animals be implanted with a microchip nor do they have a state court decision denying them compensation, the state's attorneys said.

The owners' appeal comes after a federal judge in Columbus sided with the state last year in upholding the law.

The new regulations took effect in September, although some provisions have yet to kick in. Those include a permit process that goes into place in October.

Under that process, owners who want to keep their animals must obtain new state-issued permits by Jan. 1, 2014. They must pass background checks, pay fees, obtain liability insurance or surety bonds and show inspectors they can properly contain the animals and care for them. The law exempts sanctuaries, research institutions and facilities accredited by the two national zoo groups.

In upholding the law last year, U.S. District Court Judge George Smith said the court recognizes some businesses may be negatively affected by it and some owners may not be able to keep their beloved animals, but the plaintiffs failed to prove it violates their constitutional rights.

Smith said the case came down to the public interest and protecting the public from the potential dangers of exotic animals that get loose.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

More stories

Items of Zanesville exotic animals owner being auctioned Items of Zanesville exotic animals owner being auctioned

Hundreds of curiosity-seekers, horse-traders and others have attended an auction of the estate of a suicidal man who released dozens of exotic animals in eastern Ohio almost two years ago.

State: Ohio wild animal law doesn State: Ohio wild animal law doesn't violate rights

Attorneys for Ohio told a federal appeals court Wednesday that the state's exotic animal law gives owners a pathway to keep the creatures if they choose and doesn't violate their constitutional rights.

Ohio panel to review new rules for exotic animals Ohio panel to review new rules for exotic animals

Owners of exotic animals in Ohio would be required to meet new caging, safety and caretaking standards under proposed rules slated for review Wednesday by a legislative panel.

Ohio won Ohio won't identify types of animals in exotics facility

The types of animals being held at Ohio's new holding facility for exotic creatures won't be released to the public, mainly to deter anyone from trying to gain access to them, state Agriculture Director David Daniels said Thursday.

Federal judge upholds Ohio Federal judge upholds Ohio's new exotic animal law

A federal judge has upheld Ohio's new restrictions on exotic animals after several owners sued the state over the law.

Ohio judge to hear testimony on exotic animal law Ohio judge to hear testimony on exotic animal law

A federal judge is scheduled to begin hearing testimony Monday in a lawsuit involving Ohio's new law regulating dangerous wild animals.

Judge: Humane Society can join Ohio exotic animal suit Judge: Humane Society can join Ohio exotic animal suit

A judge has ruled in favor of allowing the Humane Society of the United States to join the state in defending Ohio's new law regulating exotic animals.

Ohio governor John Kasich issues order on exotic animal rules Ohio governor John Kasich issues order on exotic animal rules

Gov. John Kasich has cleared the way for Ohio to enforce temporary rules set by a board that was created under the state's new law on exotic animals.

Officials work to get Ohio exotics owners registered Officials work to get Ohio exotics owners registered

State officials continue to work with owners of exotic animals to help them fully register their creatures with the Ohio Department of Agriculture, even though the state deadline for them to submit information was several weeks ago.

Owners Owners' lawyer: Agreement reached in exotics case

An attorney for animal owners who are suing over Ohio's new law regulating exotic wildlife says they've reached an agreement with state officials in the case.