Trayvon Martin shouts? Experts debate screams for help on 911 calls

ORLANDO, Fla. - Audio experts differ on whether screams for help captured on 911 calls are those of defendant George Zimmerman or of shooting victim 17-year-old Trayvon Martin, according to reports released Tuesday.

One New Jersey-based audio expert said in a report that the screams came from Martin, while another Florida-based audio expert said the shouts were a mix of Martin and Zimmerman.

Attorneys prosecuting Zimmerman on a charge of second-degree murder hired the audio experts to compare samples of Zimmerman's and Martin's voices with the shouts from the 911 calls phoned in by neighbors of Zimmerman. The residents of the gated community heard the neighborhood watch leader struggling with the South Florida teen during a confrontation last year. Determining whose voice was calling for help could aid a jury in deciding whether Zimmerman's claims of self-defense were justified.

Zimmerman is pleading not guilty and his trial starts next month.

Martin's family claims the voice is that of the South Florida teen, while Zimmerman's father has said in court he believes the cries are from his son.

Zimmerman's defense attorney, Mark O'Mara, has asked a judge to determine whether the audio analysis can be used at trial. O'Mara said in a filing that he was concerned the analysis of the 911 calls would prejudice jurors.

"Counsel has significant and legitimate concerns that such evidence will confuse the issues for this jury to decide, and it may well mislead the jury in this area of inquiry," O'Mara said in the filing.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

Related Stories

George Zimmerman will not face domestic violence charges, prosecutor says George Zimmerman will not face domestic violence charges, prosecutor says

Prosecutors say they will not file domestic violence charges against George Zimmerman after his girlfriend said in a sworn statement she did not want to pursue the case.

George Zimmerman released from jail after court hearing George Zimmerman released from jail after court hearing

George Zimmerman has been released from jail hours after his first court appearance on domestic violence-related charges.

George Zimmerman George Zimmerman's estranged wife Shellie won't press charges despite 911 call

The 911 call seemed frantic: George Zimmerman's sobbing estranged wife said he was threatening her and her father with a gun and she feared for her life. Please come.

George Zimmerman caught speeding again, given a $256 ticket George Zimmerman caught speeding again, given a $256 ticket

Former neighborhood watch volunteer George Zimmerman apparently has a lead foot.

Florida Juror B29 to ABC News: George Zimmerman got away with murder in death of Trayvon Martin Florida Juror B29 to ABC News: George Zimmerman got away with murder in death of Trayvon Martin

Another juror comes out from the shadows in the aftermath of the George Zimmerman verdict, sitting down with ABC News' Robin Roberts.

Ohio gun group raises $12K for George Zimmerman Ohio gun group raises $12K for George Zimmerman

An Ohio firearms group has raised more than $12,000 to buy guns or a security system for George Zimmerman.

Officials: George Zimmerman helped 4 out of wrecked SUV Officials: George Zimmerman helped 4 out of wrecked SUV

Officials say George Zimmerman helped rescue four people from an overturned vehicle last week, just days after he was cleared of all charges in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin.

Four George Zimmerman jurors release statement about trial Four George Zimmerman jurors release statement about trial

Four of the jurors at the George Zimmerman trial distanced themselves late Tuesday from statements that another juror made in a televised interview.

George Zimmerman verdict protesters raid Los Angeles store, stop freeway George Zimmerman verdict protesters raid Los Angeles store, stop freeway

Protesters ran through Los Angeles streets Monday night, breaking windows, attacking people on sidewalks and at one point raiding a Wal-Mart store in  demonstrations over George Zimmerman's Florida acquittal in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin.

Juror: George Zimmerman had right to defend himself Juror: George Zimmerman had right to defend himself

A juror in the George Zimmerman trial said Monday that the actions of the neighborhood watch volunteer and Trayvon Martin both led to the teenager's fatal shooting last year, but that Zimmerman didn't actually break the law.