Trial begins for man accused of murdering Mentor bartender Annie McSween

MENTOR, Ohio - The trial began Tuesday for Joseph Thomas, 28, the man accused of murdering Mentor resident Annie McSween.

McSween was found murdered outside of a bar called Mario's Lakeway Lounge located on Andrews Road in Mentor-on-the-Lake where she worked as a bartender on Nov. 26, 2010.

Thomas has been charged with aggravated murder, rape and other various counts. He could face the death penalty if convicted.

The trial began at 9 a.m. with a jury view and wrapped up around 5 p.m.

James Yager took the stand, the mechanic at Yager Auto & Marine Center who found McSween's body.

While inspecting boats that were vandalized, Yager said he found a shoe and women's underwear near the boats. He didn't think anything of it at first because, with the bar nearby, finding articles of clothing was not unusual.

But when Yager saw a car vandalized in the parking lot, he knew something wasn't right. That's when he noticed jewelry next to the driver's side door, a shoe up inside the wheel well that matched the shoe he found by the damaged boat. Shortly after, he stumbled upon McSween's body.

"I just figured that she was dragged to the back of the lot, so I just walked straight back, like a diagonal from the car, to the back corner behind the sailboat and behind the equipment and I just looked in the woods and there she was."

Testimony resumes at 8:30 a.m. on Wednesday.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

Related Stories

Lake County judge sentences Joseph Thomas to death row for Annie McSween murder Lake County judge sentences Joseph Thomas to death row for Annie McSween murder

A judge agreed with jurors, sentencing a man to death row for the brutal killing of a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender two years ago.

Lake County judge to decide if Joseph Thomas should get death penalty in Annie McSween murder Lake County judge to decide if Joseph Thomas should get death penalty in Annie McSween murder

Jurors have unanimously agreed the death penalty is an appropriate sentence for a man convicted of killing a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender. On Monday, a judge makes the final decision.

Jury recommends death penalty for man convicted of killing Mentor resident Annie McSween Jury recommends death penalty for man convicted of killing Mentor resident Annie McSween

A Lake County jury unanimously recommended the death penalty for Joseph Thomas, convicted of killing a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender in 2010.

Jury will decide fate of convicted Mentor-on-the-Lake killer Joseph Thomas Jury will decide fate of convicted Mentor-on-the-Lake killer Joseph Thomas

Nine defense witnesses took the stand in the sentencing phase of convicted killer Joseph Thomas Wednesday in Lake County Common Pleas Court.

Joseph Thomas returns to Lake Co. courthouse for next phase in Annie McSween murder conviction Joseph Thomas returns to Lake Co. courthouse for next phase in Annie McSween murder conviction

The man convicted in the murder of Annie McSween will begin the penalty phase at a Lake County courthouse Wednesday morning.

Joseph Thomas found guilty on all counts in Mentor-on-the-Lake murder of Annie McSween Joseph Thomas found guilty on all counts in Mentor-on-the-Lake murder of Annie McSween

The jury has found Joseph Thomas guilty on all counts in the murder of Mentor resident Annie McSween.