Jury will decide fate of convicted Mentor-on-the-Lake killer Joseph Thomas

PAINESVILLE, Ohio - Nine defense witnesses took the stand in the sentencing phase of convicted killer Joseph Thomas Wednesday in Lake County Common Pleas Court.

Thomas was convicted of killing 49-year-old Annie McSween at the Mentor-On-The-Lake bar where she worked. She was found dead on Nov. 26, 2010 near what was then called Mario's Lakeway Lounge on Andrews Road.

Thomas's mother, Verna Rodriguez, took the stand Wednesday morning in an effort to spare her son from the death penalty. She told the jury she was a crack addict, alcoholic who left her three small children.

"I was dropped off to spend the weekend, my mom never came back," testified James Thomas, Joe Thomas' brother.

Rodriguez also testified that her kids were left to care for themselves and that she left the kids behind and moved to Seattle with a boyfriend.

Thomas's sister, Tessa Rodgers, testified their father abandoned them. "I consider him a sperm donor."

Witnesses told the jury that Rodriguez went from one bad relationship to another had many relationships with different men and that all three children, including Thomas, were exposed to violence, drug abuse and excessive drinking.

James Thomas told the jury,   "we pretty much raised ourselves," he said.

The defense is expected to call 11 witnesses.

Jurors will decide if Joseph Thomas receives life in prison with or without the possibility of parole, or the death penalty.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

Related Stories

Lake County judge sentences Joseph Thomas to death row for Annie McSween murder Lake County judge sentences Joseph Thomas to death row for Annie McSween murder

A judge agreed with jurors, sentencing a man to death row for the brutal killing of a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender two years ago.

Lake County judge to decide if Joseph Thomas should get death penalty in Annie McSween murder Lake County judge to decide if Joseph Thomas should get death penalty in Annie McSween murder

Jurors have unanimously agreed the death penalty is an appropriate sentence for a man convicted of killing a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender. On Monday, a judge makes the final decision.

Jury recommends death penalty for man convicted of killing Mentor resident Annie McSween Jury recommends death penalty for man convicted of killing Mentor resident Annie McSween

A Lake County jury unanimously recommended the death penalty for Joseph Thomas, convicted of killing a Mentor-on-the-Lake bartender in 2010.

Jury will decide fate of convicted Mentor-on-the-Lake killer Joseph Thomas Jury will decide fate of convicted Mentor-on-the-Lake killer Joseph Thomas

Nine defense witnesses took the stand in the sentencing phase of convicted killer Joseph Thomas Wednesday in Lake County Common Pleas Court.

Joseph Thomas returns to Lake Co. courthouse for next phase in Annie McSween murder conviction Joseph Thomas returns to Lake Co. courthouse for next phase in Annie McSween murder conviction

The man convicted in the murder of Annie McSween will begin the penalty phase at a Lake County courthouse Wednesday morning.

Joseph Thomas found guilty on all counts in Mentor-on-the-Lake murder of Annie McSween Joseph Thomas found guilty on all counts in Mentor-on-the-Lake murder of Annie McSween

The jury has found Joseph Thomas guilty on all counts in the murder of Mentor resident Annie McSween.