Judge to Brecksville bomb plotter: Am I biased?

AKRON, Ohio - A judge ready to sentence a fourth man in a failed plot to bomb a highway bridge asked him on Thursday if he should step aside from the bench because of bias.

U.S. District Court Judge David Dowd asked the attorney for defendant Anthony Hayne to discuss the issue with Hayne before Friday's sentencing in Akron.

The issue involves comments the judge made to Cleveland's The Plain Dealer newspaper that were favorable to three co-defendants sentenced last week. The judge said if Hayne, who's from Cleveland, concludes the comments showed bias, he would remove himself from the case.

Hayne, 35, hopes his plea deal gives him half of the eight- to 11-year sentences his co-defendants got, not half the longer terms sought by the government. The judge called the longer recommendations grotesque.

On Thursday, Connor Stevens, of Berea, became the last of the other three men to appeal his sentence as too harsh. Stevens, 21, was sentenced to eight years and one month as the least involved, but the government asked for 19 years.

The judge had praised Stevens' comments court before his sentencing and predicted all three would emerge from prison as better people.

A spokesman for U.S. Attorney Steve Dettelbach said there would be no comment on the judge's bias query to Hayne. Hayne's attorney, Michael O'Shea, declined to comment.

Hayne's plea change request, filed the day the other three men were sentenced, was conditional on whether he gets a more lenient sentence than his co-defendants. His attorney said his plea deal in return for cooperation could still mean a longer sentence than the terms handed down to his co-defendants.

The co-defendants pleaded guilty after Hayne but without plea deals promising cooperation.

The men are described by the government as self-proclaimed anarchists who acted out of anger against corporate America and the government. The defense has called the investigation a case of entrapment, with an FBI informant guiding the way.

The men, who had been active in the Occupy Cleveland movement against financial inequality and what they called corporate greed, targeted a bridge over Cuyahoga Valley National Park between Cleveland and Akron, authorities said. The FBI has said that the public was never in danger and that the device was a dud provided by the informant.

A fifth co-defendant is undergoing a psychiatric exam at a federal prison outside Boston.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

Brecksville bridge bomb plot

Failed bomb plotter Joshua Stafford appeals conviction Failed bomb plotter Joshua Stafford appeals conviction

The last of five defendants sentenced in a failed anti-Wall Street plot to bomb a highway bridge in Ohio has appealed his conviction and 10-year sentence.

Man guilty in northeast Ohio bridge bomb plot, Joshua Stafford, sentenced to 10 years in jail Man guilty in northeast Ohio bridge bomb plot, Joshua Stafford, sentenced to 10 years in jail

One of the five men found guilty for their roles in a conspiracy to destroy a northeast Ohio bridge received his sentence Monday.

Sentencing set for fifth bomb plot defendant Joshua Stafford Sentencing set for fifth bomb plot defendant Joshua Stafford

The last of five defendants in a failed anti-Wall Street plot to bomb a highway bridge near Cleveland faces sentencing after losing another bid for leniency.

VIDEO: Men in Brecksville bomb plot place dud explosives at Brecksville-Northfield High Level Bridge VIDEO: Men in Brecksville bomb plot place dud explosives at Brecksville-Northfield High Level Bridge

Video released on Friday shows a group of men attempting to blow up the Brecksville-Northfield High Level Bridge last year.

Brecksville bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford found guilty on three counts Brecksville bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford found guilty on three counts

The fifth suspect in the Brecksville bomb plot was found guilty on two counts of using weapons of mass destruction and one count of explosions materials.

Final defendant, Joshua Stafford, testifies at Brecksville bridge bomb plot trial Final defendant, Joshua Stafford, testifies at Brecksville bridge bomb plot trial

The last of five suspects in a failed Ohio plot to bomb a highway bridge has taken the stand in his defense.

Prosecutor: Brecksville suspect planned to use to detonate bomb Prosecutor: Brecksville suspect planned to use to detonate bomb

A prosecutor says an Ohio bridge bomb-plotting suspect planned to use a phone to detonate what he thought were real explosives.

Jury selected for trial of bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford Jury selected for trial of bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford

The jury has been chosen in the case of Joshua Stafford, the last of five bridge bomb-plotting suspects, according to the U.S. Department of Justice.

Bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford to represent self at trial Bridge bomb plot suspect Joshua Stafford to represent self at trial

The last of five bridge bomb-plotting suspects in northeast Ohio is headed to trial and the defendant will represent himself.

Brecksville bomb suspect allowed to represent himself Brecksville bomb suspect allowed to represent himself

A federal judge will allow the last of five bridge bomb-plotting suspects in northeast Ohio to represent himself at trial.