Apple iPhone tops Samsung Galaxy S4 in durability test from SquareTrade

Don't Waste Your Money

When you're deciding what smartphone to buy, you usually consider size, cost and features.

You don't think much about durability. But a new report says maybe you should.

Glass Breaks Easily

No one wants a smartphone with a shattered screen. But it happens all too frequently when we drop them, sit on them or crush them in a purse.

Now, SquareTrade, the extended warranty company, has dropped, slid and even submerged in water some popular phones.

The Results

SquareTrade gives the new Samsung Galaxy S4 a 7 out of 10 when it comes to breakability, saying it is more prone to shattering than many other phones.

The older Galaxy S3 gets a 6.5, a little better, which mean it is less susceptible to breaking.

Apples iPhone received a much better 5 , with SquareTrade calling it "far more durable overall." Mac blogs credit the iPhones thicker metal casing and smaller glass screen.

Doesn't That Stink?

And from the doesn't that stink file, why you shouldn't carry a smartphone without a case. It's amazing how many people avoid cases because they like the sleek look of glass and aluminum.

But a drop on a sidewalk is almost guaranteed to result in a shattered screen and a replacement cost of at least $100. Doesn't that stink? Buy a case....the thicker the better.

My advice: If you are buying a phone for a child or teen, durability should be something you consider.

And if you're a bit clumsy like me, you may want to keep it in mind too so you don't waste your money.

______________________

Don't Waste Your Money is a registered trademark of the EW Scripps Co.

"Like" John Matarese on Facebook

Follow John on Twitter (@DWYM)

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

More Apple Stories

Early tests on iPhone 6: Camera struggles in low-light, 6 Plus difficult for one-hand operation Early tests on iPhone 6: Camera struggles in low-light, 6 Plus difficult for one-hand operation

Thousands of people lined up to be the first to get the new Apple phones — the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus.
Consumer Reports’ shoppers were there, too.

Considering an iPhone 6? What you need to do before getting a new phone Considering an iPhone 6? What you need to do before getting a new phone

Considering a new iPhone 6? An expert tells us how to get the most money for your current phone and how to keep your personal info safe as you transition.

How do you feel about Apple How do you feel about Apple's new announcements? You let us know

We wanted to hear from you about the big news coming out of Apple today. We caught up with people coming out of the Apple store at Eton.

LIVE: Apple product announcement; event already being called LIVE: Apple product announcement; event already being called 'historic'

Apple says you can order iPhone, iPhone 6 starting Sept. 12.
 

Unexplained rash? Your iPad may be to blame Unexplained rash? Your iPad may be to blame

The popular tablet computer may contain nickel, one of the most common allergy-inducing metals.

iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner

John Matarese has a preview of Apple's upcoming new iPhone

Disney Movies Anywhere app and service lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar, Marvel movies Disney Movies Anywhere app and service lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar, Marvel movies

The new Disney Movies Anywhere app lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar and Marvel movies from anywhere.

Flappy Birds disappears from app stores; Creator Dong Nguyen pulls it down Flappy Birds disappears from app stores; Creator Dong Nguyen pulls it down

Flappy Birds disappears from app stores after creator tweets "I can't take it anymore."

Lingering glitches with Apple Lingering glitches with Apple's iOS 7 and Microsoft's Windows 8 haunt gadgets

John Matarese looks into all the glitches with recent product updates in Don't Waste Your Money.

Apple event live streaming coverage: (AAPL) expected to unveil its line of iPad tablets for holidays Apple event live streaming coverage: (AAPL) expected to unveil its line of iPad tablets for holidays

Apple unveiled a new, thinner, lighter tablet called the "iPad Air" along with a slew of new Macs ahead of the holiday shopping season as it faces growing competition from rival gadget makers.