Consumer Reports weighs in on iPhone 5 and whether you should buy one

iPhone 5 plug problems

NEW YORK - Consumer Reports is ready to put the new iPhone 5 through its battery of tests once the shipments start.

The organization expects the phone will perform well, as only the iPhone 4 had problems and that was a unique issue with its antenna. The early drawback deals with the adapters for the phone.

"The new connector on the bottom, which is a lot smaller. It won't fit. The new iPhone won't be able to dock with the accessories that are out there now. If you've invested a lot in speaker systems and other docks out there you are going to need an adaptor and Apple is going to charge $30 for one of those," Consumer Reports Senior Electronics Editor Mike Gikas said.

The adapter won't be available until October, and video and iPod out will not be supported.

So why did they do it? Gikas said it was necessary to keep the phone thin. As the screens get bigger, keeping the phone thin and light is a challenge.

The upsides to the iPhone 5 are that its screen is bigger, and it's 4G. So, users will see faster download speeds. The phone also is an LTE phone, so you'll see even faster download speeds if there is a 4G LTE network in your area.

Want to know more about 4G LTE? Our consumer team put it to the test .

Consumer Reports said there isn't as big a need to run out and buy one.

"The only reason to buy this new phone is if you really want an iPhone and you were put off by that smaller screen. And now the new model has a larger screen and faster data connection that all those Android users have been enjoying for the last two years. That's really the only reason," Gikas said.

Gikas also said don't switch if you are grandfathered in to an unlimited data plan. With the new tiered plans, you'll likely pay $10 more a month, if not more. It all depends on how much data you use.

Print this article Back to Top

Comments

More Apple Stories

Early tests on iPhone 6: Camera struggles in low-light, 6 Plus difficult for one-hand operation Early tests on iPhone 6: Camera struggles in low-light, 6 Plus difficult for one-hand operation

Thousands of people lined up to be the first to get the new Apple phones — the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus.
Consumer Reports’ shoppers were there, too.

Considering an iPhone 6? What you need to do before getting a new phone Considering an iPhone 6? What you need to do before getting a new phone

Considering a new iPhone 6? An expert tells us how to get the most money for your current phone and how to keep your personal info safe as you transition.

How do you feel about Apple How do you feel about Apple's new announcements? You let us know

We wanted to hear from you about the big news coming out of Apple today. We caught up with people coming out of the Apple store at Eton.

LIVE: Apple product announcement; event already being called LIVE: Apple product announcement; event already being called 'historic'

Apple says you can order iPhone, iPhone 6 starting Sept. 12.
 

Unexplained rash? Your iPad may be to blame Unexplained rash? Your iPad may be to blame

The popular tablet computer may contain nickel, one of the most common allergy-inducing metals.

iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner iPhone 6 plans leaked: Bigger, thinner

John Matarese has a preview of Apple's upcoming new iPhone

Disney Movies Anywhere app and service lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar, Marvel movies Disney Movies Anywhere app and service lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar, Marvel movies

The new Disney Movies Anywhere app lets Apple users buy and watch Disney, Pixar and Marvel movies from anywhere.

Flappy Birds disappears from app stores; Creator Dong Nguyen pulls it down Flappy Birds disappears from app stores; Creator Dong Nguyen pulls it down

Flappy Birds disappears from app stores after creator tweets "I can't take it anymore."

Lingering glitches with Apple Lingering glitches with Apple's iOS 7 and Microsoft's Windows 8 haunt gadgets

John Matarese looks into all the glitches with recent product updates in Don't Waste Your Money.

Apple event live streaming coverage: (AAPL) expected to unveil its line of iPad tablets for holidays Apple event live streaming coverage: (AAPL) expected to unveil its line of iPad tablets for holidays

Apple unveiled a new, thinner, lighter tablet called the "iPad Air" along with a slew of new Macs ahead of the holiday shopping season as it faces growing competition from rival gadget makers.