'Zero Dark Thirty' take on bin Laden raid courted controversy from start

bin Laden compound_20110504150838_JPG

ABBOTTABAD, PAKISTAN - MAY 3: People gather outside Osama Bin Laden's compound, where he was killed during a raid by U.S. special forces, May 3, 2011 in Abottabad, Pakistan. Bin Laden was killed during a U.S. military mission May 2, at the…

advertisement

Posted: 12/04/2012

The new movie about the hunt for Osama bin Laden didn't even have a title when controversy began swirling around how it was made.

Now the movie is officially called "Zero Dark Thirty," and still some in Washington are concerned about what access the filmmakers had to classified information about the biggest intelligence effort in decades.

"Obviously things went wrong here," said Rep. Peter King (R-New York). "My understanding is that the Hollywood people got access to CIA operatives, CIA locations ... that they had access to the Navy SEALs, which they should not have had."

King said the filmmakers, director Kathryn Bigelow and screenwriter Mark Boal, attended a special event at the CIA for the real-life Bin Laden hunters.

"There was an event where operatives were involved, and they did not know until they got there that the Hollywood people were going to be present, which means identity would have been shown," King said.

CNN spoke with Bigelow and Boal, who were also the movie's producers. They are saying very little about whom they had access to and what they saw.

"I am not going to discuss the specifics steps that we took in researching the film other than to say we worked through government agencies where appropriate and did independent reporting where appropriate," Boal said.

"It's definitely nice to have the film out there," Bigelow said. "It's been so kind of debated, obviously a bit of controversy that's surrounded it. And I think it's nice because now the film can speak for itself."

The film was in the planning stages before a team of Navy SEALs killed bin Laden in his home in Abbottabad, Pakistan. That meant the old script had to be tossed and a whole new script written.

That's where the controversy began. The conservative watchdog group Judicial Watch said it has records from the Defense Department and CIA that show that the Obama Administration "granted Boal and Bigelow unusual access to agency information for their film."

Judicial Watch said that the Obama administration helped with the film because it would "portray Barack Obama as 'gutsy'." But the finished film contains only a few references to the president, and not all of them are flattering. At one point, Obama's policies on detainees are portrayed as hindering the hunt for bin Laden.

The CIA and Pentagon have begun investigations into whether there was undue access. Pentagon and CIA officials have said that none of the access jeopardized sources or gave away classified information about the operation.

King questions whether service members felt pressured to deal with the producers, suggesting to CNN that "some resisted, some acquiesced."

A senior military official denies that any Navy SEALs were pressured to cooperate on the film.

Boal said that the filmmakers went to great lengths to make sure that their portrayal would not jeopardize military secrets.

For example, they built models of the stealth helicopters used in the raid. Their models were based on pictures of what remained of one of the helicopters that crashed in the raid and additional educated guesses made by aviation experts.

After the models were created, Boal and Bigelow sent pictures of their pretend stealth helicopters to the Pentagon to make the models weren't too accurate.

The movie, which was originally scheduled to be released before the election, is now set for limited release on December 19 and wide release in January.

Copyright CNN

  • Comments
  • More bin Laden Coverage
Court: US can keep Osama bin Laden before/after raid photos under wraps
Court: bin Laden photos can stay hidden

A federal appeals court is backing the U.S. government's …

Bin Laden son-in-law, spokesman pleads not guilty to plot
Bin Laden son-in-law pleads not guilty

A senior al-Qaida leader and son-in-law of Osama bin Laden, …

Lawmakers say CIA may have misled filmmakers
Lawmakers: CIA may have misled…

Lawmakers accused the CIA of misleading the makers of the Osama…

Panetta suggests bin Laden book author could be penalized
bin Laden book author could face…

A former Navy SEAL who wrote a book about his personal account …

Release date moved up for SEAL's book on bin Laden raid
SEAL's book on bin Laden raid moved up

The publisher of a firsthand account of the raid that killed al…

Documents released: Osama bin Laden's last words go online
Osama bin Laden's last words go online

In letters from his last hideout, Osama bin Laden fretted about…

US tells court bin Laden photos must stay secret
US: bin Laden photos must stay secret

The Obama administration is arguing that public disclosure of …

Bin Laden targeted Air Force One, sporting events
Osama bin Laden targeted Air Force One

U.S. officials say that Osama Bin Laden wanted to assemble a …

The man who hunted Osama bin Laden
The man who hunted Osama bin Laden

The CIA will not permit him to speak with reporters. But …

Advertisement

National Headlines


  1. Men's Wearhouse fires face of company

    Men's Wearhouse fires face of company

    Apparently, Men's Wearhouse Inc. doesn't like the way its founder looks anymore.

    • FBI ends hunt for Jimmy Hoffa's remains

      FBI ends hunt for Jimmy Hoffa's remains

      The excavation of a rural field in suburban Detroit has failed to turn up the remains of former Teamsters union leader Jimmy Hoffa.

      • NASA asking for help to find asteroids

      • Mayors push to limit food stamps for pop

        • Serena Williams comments on Steubenville

        • Tornado touches down near Denver airport

          • Man mauled after feeding bear BBQ

            • Trending now on newsnet5
             
            • Stay Connected

            Send us a News Tip Send us a News Tip
            Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps
            Twitter Twitter
            Facebook Facebook
            YouTube YouTube
            Community Calendar Community Calendar
            RSS Feeds RSS Feeds
            ClevelandLaw.tv ClevelandLaw.tv