James Holmes court documents in the Aurora, Colorado, theater shooting released Friday

Papers say Holmes sent burnt money with notebook

James Holmes_20120723114334_JPG

James Holmes, the man accused of killing 12 people and injuring dozens more in a Colorado movie theater shooting rampage on Friday July 20, 2012, makes his first court appearance.

james_holmes_2_20120720130321_JPG

A court document filed last week revealed that James Holmes was a patient of CU psychiatrist Lynne Fenton before the July 20 killings.
Photographer: thedenverchannel.com

shooting13


Photographer: Getty Images

advertisement

Posted: 09/28/2012

AURORA, Colo - Documents released Friday in the theater shooting case show suspect James Holmes apparently didn't just send a notebook to his psychiatrist, but also burnt currency.

That new information comes in a document filed by the prosecution on Aug. 14. In that motion, the prosecution argues why the items sent to a CU-Denver psychiatrist should be seen by the court.

"The notebook and the burnt currency are not ______ [blacked out]. Until and unless reviewed by this court, nobody knows what they are, or even whether they would be, in any way related to ____ [blacked out]. Based on the circumstances, it is highly unlikely that they would _____ [blacked out] or privileged in any way," the prosecution said.

The court released 57 documents on Friday that were filed by prosecutors, defense attorneys and the media. The documents include small exhibit items like the copy of an exhibit envelope from a motions hearing and important motions such as the request that the package sent to the University of Colorado remain sealed and be turned over to the court or defense attorneys.

In one document, defense attorneys protest comments prosecutors made in court. NewsChannel5 Scripps sister station 7NEWS has already reported that in court, prosecutors said Holmes was "denied access" to the school [CU-Denver] "after he made threats to a professor." However, the defense said a spokesperson for the school said Holmes was never banned from campus.

That prompted defense attorneys to ask that prosecutors be sanctioned for what the defense team called "prosecution's reckless disregard for the truth." The judge ruled it was not a deliberate mischaracterization by the people and the sanctions were denied by the judge.

The documents show that prosecutors wanted more information about an expert the defense is reportedly using as an advisory witness.  The defense gave the prosecution the curriculum vitae of the defense expert, however, it is blacked out in the document release so as not to reveal the person to the public.

See all of the documents released to the public since the shooting.

While some expected the new documents to shed more light on what prosecutors say led to the July 20 shooting at the Century 16 theater, most of the documents appear to be typical procedural filings.

Former University of Colorado, Denver, neuroscience graduate student James Holmes, 24, faces 152 charges in the shooting that killed 12 people and injured 58 others.

Defense attorneys claim Holmes is mentally ill and sought the help of a university psychiatrist before the shooting, raising the possibility that Holmes will plead not guilty by reason of insanity.

In court, prosecutors raised the prospect that Holmes was angry at the failure of a once promising academic career and stockpiled weapons, ammunition, tear gas grenades, and body armor as his research deteriorated and professors urged him to get into another profession. Chief Deputy District Attorney Karen Pearson said Holmes failed a key oral exam in June, was banned from campus and began to voluntarily withdraw from the school.

Key information in the case gleaned from previous court documents includes:

Confirmation that Holmes sent a package to CU psychiatrist Lynne Fenton. In the document, defense attorneys Daniel King and Tamara Brady described Fenton as Holmes' psychiatrist, although prosecutors have said that their doctor-patient relationship ended on June 11, weeks before the attack. The package contains a notebook that reportedly includes descriptions and drawings of an attack, but Fenton said she never saw the notebook.

Information from prosecutors that Holmes in March spoke with another student about killing people "when his life was over."

Prosecutors and defense attorneys had asked that court documents be sealed to preserve an ongoing investigation and protect Holmes' right to a fair trial. Sylvester ordered that some information in the documents that will be released have information blacked out to protect the identities of witnesses.

Documents that won't be released include an arrest affidavit, which contains information about the investigation, as well as requests for search warrants and subpoenas.

In his order, Sylvester noted that some information contained in court documents had been divulged in court and placing limits on what's released balances the public's First Amendment rights to see the court file, and prosecutors' and defense attorneys' concerns.

Holmes to submit DNA and palm print

The judge overseeing the case issued an order Tuesday allowing authorities to collect a palm print and DNA sample from Holmes.

Prosecutors argued that they needed the print from Holmes to compare it with a print found on the inside of a theater exit door, as well as a DNA sample for comparing with other evidence collected by investigators.

Theater

Victims and witnesses of the Aurora theater shooting may be allowed to go back inside the theater.

The Arapahoe County District Attorney’s

office sent an email to the victims

this week telling them the news, according to an exclusive report by ABC News.

“The theater remains concerned about the Victims’ and Witnesses’ well-being and is open to the possibility of potential visits to the theater,” the email read. 

It instructs victims on how to get more information about the potential visits, but there are no dates or times given.  The email said representatives of Cinemark, owners of the Century 16 theater, asked the district attorney’s office to relay the information.

Theater officials announced last week that they plan to reopen the theater in 2013.

"It will be our privilege to re-open the theater. We pledge to reconfigure the space and make the theater better than ever," said Cinemark President and CEO Tim Warner in a letter to Aurora's mayor.

Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
  • Related stories
Colorado theater shooting suspect James Holmes to get mental evaluation
James Holmes to get mental evaluation

James Holmes, the former neuroscience graduate student accused …

Judge accepts James Holmes' insanity plea in Colorado theater shooting case
Judge accepts James Holmes insanity…

A judge on Tuesday accepted James' Holmes plea of not guilty by…

Colorado theater shooting suspect James Holmes could enter insanity plea Tuesday
James Holmes could enter insanity plea

The suspect in the Colorado theater massacre could enter his …

Judge delays decision on Colorado movie theater James Holmes insanity plea
Decision on Holmes insanity plea…

Lawyers for the Colorado theater shooting suspect say he wants …

Colorado shootings suspect James Holmes to enter insanity plea
Colorado shooting suspect insanity plea

Lawyers for the man accused of killing 12 people and injuring …

Lawyers hint at insanity plea without James Holmes' OK in Colorado movie theater shooting
Lawyers hint at plea without Holmes' OK

Attorneys for the Colorado theater shooting suspect suggested …

James Holmes Colorado shooting: Psychiatrist warned University of Colorado police before assault
Holmes psychiatrist warned of danger

New questions are confronting the university that Colorado …

Colorado judge orders release of documents on James Holmes in movie theater shooting
Judge orders release of Holmes…

The new Colorado judge overseeing the theater shooting case has…

US seeking death penalty against James Holmes in Colorado movie theater shooting
US seeking death penalty in CO shooting

Prosecutors want James Holmes executed for last year's attack …

Colorado theater massacre suspect James Holmes to learn if he faces execution
Massacre suspect to learn if faces…

After a week of legal twists and turns, James Holmes will find …

Advertisement

National Headlines


  1. Mayors push to limit food stamps for pop

    Mayors push to limit food stamps for pop

    The mayors of New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and 15 other cities are reviving a push against letting food stamps be used to buy soda and other sugary drinks.

    • Serena Williams comments on Steubenville

      Serena Williams comments on Steubenville

      Serena Williams says in an interview with Rolling Stone magazine that, while not blaming the victim in the Steubenville rape case, "she shouldn't have put herself in that position."

      • Tornado touches down near Denver airport

        • Man mauled after feeding bear BBQ

          • Flasher exposes himself at Target

          • Fox gets head stuck in glass jar

          • Chrysler to formally reject Jeep recall

          • Trending now on newsnet5
           
          • Stay Connected

          Send us a News Tip Send us a News Tip
          Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps
          Twitter Twitter
          Facebook Facebook
          YouTube YouTube
          Community Calendar Community Calendar
          RSS Feeds RSS Feeds
          ClevelandLaw.tv ClevelandLaw.tv