Great-grandmother appears in TV political ad for and against Issue 2 creating controversy

Issue 2 ad flap


Photographer: WEWS
Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

advertisement

Posted: 10/12/2011

CLEVELAND - Opponents of Senate Bill 5, who want you to vote "no" on Issue 2, put out a TV political ad starring Cincinnati great-grandmother, Marlene Quinn, who says firefighters saved the life of her great grandchild, Zoey.

In the ad, she wants Issue 2 defeated because she said Senate Bill 5 restricts unions like firefighters from collective bargaining on issues like staffing.

But supporters of Issue 2 took a clip of the great-grandmother from that ad, and placed her in their ad making it appear she supports Issue 2. Opponents of Issue 2 from "We Are Ohio" say that's not just dirty politics, it's tricking and confusing voters.

Cleveland firefighter and union rep Michael Norman is upset with supporters from "Building A Better Ohio," saying they hijacked the ad, twisting her words to make voters think she wants you to vote yes on Issue two, keeping SB 5 a law.

"It's a blatant attempt to deceive the voters and taking the sentiment of a grandmother, who feels she owes the lives of her grandchildren to adequately staffed fire departments, and using that against the firefighters themselves," Norman said.

A number of TV stations around the state have pulled the "Building A Better Ohio" ad, but the group defends the ad as legal and fair.

"When this woman put herself on TV in support of a political position, she made herself a public figure and we have every right to run our ad and we're standing by our ad," said Connie Wehrkamp, spokesperson for "Building a Better Ohio."

NewsChannel5 has received several e-mails from viewers saying the "Build A Better Ohio" ad should be pulled from the air for using Quinn without her permission. One viewer named Maureen wrote "Shame on Building A Better Ohio for stealing the grandmother's words without her permission and using them in a deceiving and inaccurate ad!" TV stations around Ohio have pulled the ad.

NewsChannel5 is still running the ad because according to the attorney for the parent company Scripps Media, "We don't want to be seen as limiting or censoring public debate on a matter of significant political importance in Ohio."

There are 27 days until Election Day on Nov. 8.

Copyright 2011 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

  • Comments
Advertisement
  • More Stories
Ohio, SEIU negotiators reach tentative labor deal
OH, SEIU reach tentative labor deal

Leaders of a union representing 4,000 state workers say they've…

Is Ohio turning blue? Democrats see opportunity in Issue 2 during VP Joe Biden rally in Euclid
Democrats look to build on Issue 2 win

One week after Issue 2 was soundly defeated, Democrats look to …

Ban proposed on re-enacting repealed law

Democrats in the Ohio Senate are proposing a constitutional amendment that would put a …

New Jersey governor: Ohio union win won't affect his efforts
NJ gov: SB-5 won't affect his efforts

Gov. Chris Christie angered public employee unions by winning …

Ohio vote shows unions still a political force
Vote shows unions still political force

Labor unions are celebrating one of their biggest victories in …

Gov. John Kasich: 'People have spoken' rejecting union law, Senate Bill 5
Gov: 'People have spoken' rejecting SB5

Ohio's governor says "the people have spoken" in rejecting the …

Voters reject Issue 2, Ohio's collective bargaining law
Ohio voters turn down Issue 2

Ohio's new law limiting the collective bargaining abilities of …

AFL-CIO president in Cleveland to lead final union charge in battle over Issue 2
Trumka leads vote no push on Issue 2

The nation's top labor leader was in Cleveland Monday leading …

Ohio Gov. John Kasich rallies for Issue 2 in Cuyahoga County
Kasich hits Cuyahoga for Issue 2 rally

Gov. John Kasich took the fight for Issue 2 to Cuyahoga County …

Governor John Kasich takes push for Issue 2 to Portage County
Vote yes on Issue 2 rally in Ravenna

Gov. John Kasich joins supporters of Issue 2 at a rally in …

Local News Headlines


  1. Maple Hts. native an OK tornado survivor

    Maple Hts. native an OK tornado survivor

    A northeast Ohio native is among those in Oklahoma who are picking up the pieces of their lives after a massive tornado tore through earlier this week.

  2. Vault: Jimmy Buffett live from Blossom

    Vault: Jimmy Buffett live from Blossom

    Jimmy Buffett writes children’s books, nearly quit his music career when he missed a flight and was on the WEWS nationally-syndicated rock music show Upbeat.

  3. Wind machine used to help curb frost

  4. App helps guide Metro Park visitors

  5. LIST: Memorial Day parades, services

    • Students spread kindness, give back

    • Suspect in Trotter murder released

    • Trending now on newsnet5
     
    • Stay Connected

    Send us a News Tip Send us a News Tip
    Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps Mobile & iPhone/Android Apps
    Twitter Twitter
    Facebook Facebook
    YouTube YouTube
    Community Calendar Community Calendar
    RSS Feeds RSS Feeds
    ClevelandLaw.tv ClevelandLaw.tv