CLEVELAND - The quiet, colorful streets of fall in small town northern Ohio can be so serene. The leaves lying lazily along sidewalks. Halloween decorations displayed on lawns.
But a crime scarier than any ghost or goblin shattered autumn's laid-back attitude in Lorain County 29 years ago. A 33-year-old boy scout leader, Curtis Whiton, took members of his pack to a house of horrors, as described in court documents. Police said that little boys trusted Whiton, who raped and sodomized them.
Amherst retired police chief Lonnie Dillon was a detective in September 1983. He led the sex abuse investigation of Curtis Whiton. The case involved more than 30 boys and the accusations didn't surprise Dillon. Dillon attended high school with Whiton.
"He was very different, he stood out from pretty much everybody else," Dillon said.
Whiton led cub scouts troops in Elyria. Chief Dillon became involved in the case because Whiton brought the scouts to his house on Tenney Street in Amherst. Inside, Dillon found a mattress, pornographic material and a television.
" Whiton's family owned the home, but it wasn't his as I recall. It was not occupied," noted Dillon.
But according to police documents, one of Whiton's brothers claimed he didn't know anything about his brother's activities and the family didn't get along well. Regardless of what Whiton's family did or didn't know, Chief Dillon said he believed Whiton perfectly matched the profile of a pedophile.
"When Elyria police officers arrested him and asked me to follow up, I knew what the complaint was going to be," Dillon explained.
Generations of families live in the neighborhood. Some remember seeing young boys around the house but were surprised to learn of what went on inside. One resident told NewsChannel5 that back then (29 years ago), these types of things were rare. Now a days, she said she's not surprised. Others noted to police that Whiton seemed anxious, disheveled and always appeared to wear the same clothes.
So did residents miss the signs of the sadistic behavior the boys suffered? Chief Dillon doesn't think so, but said awareness is key to stopping predators.
"Be very active in your child's life and make sure you know who they are running around with," cautioned Dillon.
Copyright 2012 Scripps Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Our exclusive look into the Boy Scouts' confidential files – 30,000 documents, 10 journalists, 6 months of research. Our investigation reveals scouts’ pleas for help being ignored while some scout leaders were promised confidentiality.
The Scripps National Investigative Team tracks systemic problems within the Boy Scouts of America, including poor background checks, and suspected molestors moving from troop to troop. More of our exclusive interview with the leader of BSA.
After revelations of abuse within the Boy Scouts of America, how has the organization and its policies changed, and are changes working? You’ll hear different sides. Plus, a one-time abused scout has to decide whether scouting is right for his sons.
Patrick Boyle was the first to publish reports of the Boy Scouts of America's confidential "ineligible volunteers" files, in 1994. Boyle says the attention these files are now getting will do good for kids.
An official response to our investigation from Boy Scouts of America national president Wayne Perry.
Look at the confidential documents in Hoefling's file. Hoefling was a troop leader near Detroit.
Examine for yourself: the documents in his confidential files. To this day, Liska said he doesn’t know if national Scouting officials approved his application because they were unaware of his past conviction -- or if they knew about it but decided he was fit nonetheless.
Click to view confidential documents in his file. Herrick is currently serving a 95-year sentence.